How do Alberta’s draft caribou plans measure up? 

Alberta’s draft caribou plans for the Caribou Mountains, Red Earth and Berland subregions versus the federal Range Plan Guideline 

Engagement Opportunities are Available
The government has extended the timeline for written feedback on the draft caribou plans until February 1, 2027. For the Caribou Mountain sub-region submit here; for the Red Earth sub-region submit here; and for the Berland sub-region submit here. 

Under the Agreement for the conservation and recovery of the woodland caribou in Alberta signed by the federal and Alberta governments in 2020, the Government of Alberta (GOA) is obligated to develop caribou range plans as a conservation measure.  The GOA agreed that this would be accomplished using the mechanism of sub-regional planning under the Alberta Land Stewardship Act (ALSA).  Furthermore, the agreement provides that those range plans will follow the federal Range Plan Guidance for Woodland Caribou, Boreal Population. 

The caribou ranges identified in the agreement include both boreal caribou ranges (i.e. Bistcho, Yates, Caribou Mountains, Chinchaga, Red Earth, Richardson, Nipisi, Slave Lake, Cold Lake, Little Smoky, Athabasca (west and east sides) and southern mountain caribou ranges (i.e. Narraway, Redrock-Prairie Creek, À La Pêche, Jasper and Banff). 

Plans have been completed for the Cold Lake, Bistcho Lake and Upper Smoky sub-regions (see ELC’s blog posts here and here).  And this summer the GOA released draft sub-regional plans for the Caribou Mountains, Red Earth and Berland subregions (see ELC’s recent blog post). Although developed as part of Alberta’s obligations for caribou range planning under the agreement with the federal government, the draft plans clearly prioritize working landscapes over caribou habitat maintenance and protection.  The draft range plans also fail to meet the agreement to follow the federal Range Plan Guidance for Woodland Caribou, Boreal Population.  This blog will look at what the conservation agreement says, what the federal Range Plan Guideline requires, and how the draft range plans compare. 

The Canada-Alberta Conservation Agreement  

Under section 11 of the federal Species at Risk Act (SARA), the federal government may enter into a conservation agreement with any government in Canada, organization or person to benefit a species at risk or enhance its survival in the wild. Conservation agreements must provide for the taking of conservation measures and may include measures for: 

  • monitoring species status; 
  • developing and implementing education and public awareness programs; 
  • developing and implementing recovery strategies, action plans and management plans;  
  • protecting the species’ habitat, including critical habitat; or 
  • undertaking research projects in support of recovery efforts for the species. 

Pursuant to this provision, the federal and Alberta governments entered into the Agreement for the conservation and recovery of the woodland caribou in Alberta (Agreement) in October 2020.  The overarching goal of the Agreement is to “support the conservation and recovery of the woodland caribou populations to naturally self-sustaining status, consistent with the population and distribution objectives and critical habitat outcomes outlined in the Recovery Strategies and aligned with A Woodland Caribou Policy for Alberta (2011)” [section 2].  The purpose of the Agreement is to set out measures taken by the federal government and GOA to achieve that goal and will include “management and monitoring of important areas for woodland caribou, biophysical habitat attributes, and achievement and maintenance of a minimum 65% undisturbed habitat… measures will align with ECCC’s Range Plan Guidance for Woodland Caribou, Boreal Population (2016) and include: landscape planning; habitat conservation, management, and recovery; mortality and population management; and population and habitat monitoring” [section 2]. 

In the Agreement, the Government of Alberta (GOA) agreed to implement, via subregional plans, range plans for the southern mountain and boreal populations of woodland caribou located in Alberta by 2025.  The Agreement defines “range plans” as [section 1]: 

… plans, consistent with ECCC’s Range Plan Guidance for Woodland Caribou, Boreal Population (2016), that provide monitoring and science information on a woodland caribou local population or group of local populations, as well as actions required to conserve and recover that woodland caribou local population range-specific land and resource management activities will occur over space and time to protect and recover woodland caribou critical habitat.  This includes managing for important areas for woodland caribou, biophysical habitat, and establishing an ongoing minimum of 65% of the range as undisturbed habitat.  Range plans may be stand-alone documents, or part of other planning document.  Range plans could inform and be informed by broader land-use planning decision making, such as subregional planning. 

There is also a definition of “subregional plan” in the Agreement [section 1]: 

… an outcomes-based plan that is enabled through the Alberta Land Stewardship Act to address location, issue-specific challenges, and cumulative effects by providing clear operational direction, and must be considered when making decisions within the defined subregion.  A subregional plan may include regulations, conditions, directives, zones, targets, and thresholds to achieve desired woodland caribou recovery outcomes.  In areas of the province where woodland caribou occur, a subregional plan will incorporate key components identified in ECCC’s Range Plan Guidance for Woodland Caribou, Boreal Population (2016). 

In addition to the completion of caribou range plans (i.e. landscape planning), the GOA also agreed to several measures related to habitat conservation, management and recovery; and mortality and population management.  These measures include alignment of forest management plans and harvesting operations with the critical habitat outcomes set out in the Recovery Strategies; the pursuit of agreements with energy companies to support caribou conservation and recovery objectives; and access management planning consistent with caribou conservation and recovery objectives.  As well, the GOA agreed to ensure project approval conditions for energy, forestry and other land uses minimize impacts, including cumulative impacts, to caribou critical habitat, individuals and populations. 

The federal Range Plan Guideline 

The federal Range Plan Guidance for Woodland Caribou, Boreal Population is intended to assist jurisdictions in the preparation of range plans within their boundaries.  A range plan may be a stand-alone document or be part of other planning documents and is meant to outline how a given range will be managed over space and time to ensure that critical habitat is protected from destruction.  A range plan should address landscape level planning and habitat management aspects of recovery but is not designed to address local population monitoring and management (that is the purpose of action planning). 

While the federal Range Plan Guideline acknowledges that there is no single prescriptive approach to developing a range plan and that jurisdictions may select the approach they consider most appropriate, a suggested template is provided (and summarized as a range plan checklist in Appendix 1).  The template consists of four components:  contextual section, habitat section, monitoring section and timelines section.  Under the template, the context section should outline Alberta’s recovery planning process, the range plan development process and the local population self-sustainability status.  The monitoring section should include habitat condition and protection measures monitoring.  The timelines section should provide timelines for reporting on implementation and monitoring, and for range plan updates.   

Not surprisingly, the bulk of a range plan’s content is found in the habitat section.  Firstly, the range plan should outline the current habitat condition and important areas for caribou by providing information around habitat condition and disturbance levels, and information around biophysical attributes and patterns of habitat use by caribou.  Secondly, the range plan should provide information around managing the 65% undisturbed habitat including the biophysical attributes and location of the undisturbed habitat.  The plan should indicate areas that presently contribute to 65% undisturbed habitat; areas that do not and will not contribute to the 65% undisturbed habitat; and areas that will be or are being restored or naturally regenerated (i.e. will eventually contribute to the 65% undisturbed habitat).  This could be illustrated using a habitat condition balance sheet.  Thirdly, the range plan should provide information about critical habitat protection.  This includes discussion of range-specific activities likely to result in the destruction of critical habitat, the current protection for critical habitat on non-federal lands, and steps being taken by the jurisdiction.   

The range plans may be used by the federal government as evidence of critical habitat protection under the Environment and Climate Change Canada’s (ECCC) Critical Habitat Protection Assessment (CHPA) process.  The ECCC uses the CHPA process to assess the protection of critical habitat on non-federal land for terrestrial species at risk.  In this process, the ECCC assesses provincial laws, federal measures and the risk of critical habitat destruction.  Range plans themselves can be considered conservation measures if: 

  • the range plan guidance is followed and the information provided is technically sound;  
  • the range plan includes (or is accompanied by) a policy or program statement formally adopted by the jurisdiction along with resourcing commitments; and  
  • the jurisdiction has a strong history of following through with policy statements or other evidence that the policy position will be reliable as a mechanism to ensure destruction of critical habitat does not occur. 

The range plan should include any information pertinent to the Minister of ECCC in assessing whether critical habitat protection is in place or being pursued.  This includes an indication of what legislative and regulatory provisions, statutory authorizations or contractually binding agreements are intended to be used to protect critical habitat.  If the Minister determines that there is not sufficient provincial protection in place, then the Minister is required to recommend that a protection order under sections 34 and/or 61 of the Species of Risk Act be made.  Section 34 allows for safety net orders which extend the protections of the SARA (i.e. no killing, destruction of nests/dens and so on) to apply to non-federal lands in a province.  Section 61 allows for critical habitat orders which prohibit the destruction of any part of critical habitat identified in the order on non-federal lands within a province. 

How do the draft sub- regional plans compare to the federal Range Plan Guideline? 

In short, not great.  Each of the draft sub-regional plans makes a simple statement that the goal is to achieve 65% undisturbed habitat at 100 years.  Ostensibly this will occur as a result of some restrictions on industry activities and access management, and requirements for restoration of caribou biophysical habitat.  However, there is no indication of baseline critical habitat levels, no critical habitat monitoring plan, no critical habitat thresholds or indicators established, and no future modelling of critical habitat.  At the same time, each of the draft sub-regional plans prominently adopts a commitment to doubling oil and gas production within the sub-region and to allowing continued industrial activity in much of the sub-region. 

Federal Range Plan Checklist Item (Guideline, Appendix A)Appears in Draft Plan (Y/N)Comments

A. Context Section

Describe any recovery/management goals identified for the jurisdictionYOnly a simple statement that goal is to achieve 65% undisturbed habitat at 100 years.
List provincial policy statements and planning documents and explain how they link to range planningN 
Outline process followed to develop the range planN 
Provide status of self-sustainability for the local populationN 

B. Habitat Section

Current habitat condition and important areas for boreal caribou – map and describe habitat condition and disturbance levels for two time periodsNThere are no historical, current or projected critical habitat levels provided.
Current habitat condition and important areas for boreal caribou – map and describe important areas for caribou based on biophysical attributes and patterns of habitat use by boreal caribouYOnly some aspects of this component are covered.   Appendix C of each draft plan describes biophysical attributes of caribou habitat.  Also indicates that further guidance is being used by GOA and will be published soon.
Managing the 65% undisturbed habitat
Describe the measures and steps the jurisdiction is and will be taking to manage the interaction between human disturbance, natural disturbance, and the need to maintain or establish an ongoing, dynamic state of a minimum of 65% of the range as undisturbed habitat by identifying:   areas that currently contribute to 65% undisturbed habitat;areas that do not and will not contribute to the 65% undisturbed habitat; andareas that will be or are naturally regenerating or being restored – include restoration strategyNZonation approach is used to manage activities – identifying areas where human activity will continue as always (go zone); where restoration of caribou habitat is a priority (compartment A of the go zone); and where human activities will be curtailed (nature first zone).   The areas are indicated by map but it is not obvious what percentage of the subregion falls within each zone and how these align with critical habitat.
For ranges with less than 65% undisturbed habitat, demonstrate an increase in the quantity of undisturbed habitat over timeNThere are no future projections, interim thresholds, baselines, or monitoring criteria.
Critical habitat protection
Identify range-specific activities that are likely to result in destruction of critical habitat for each relevant industryN 
Outline the protection that is currently in place for critical habitat on non-federal lands, including legally-binding instruments and conservation measuresN 
In ranges where protection is not fully in place identify the steps being taken by the jurisdiction to put measures in placeYThe subregional plans indicate there will be a zonation approach to regulating activity, and restoration of footprint will be required.  However, the approaches generally allow activities to continue with little restriction and little imperative to restore within the subregional plans.  There is no mention of how these measures will be implemented or enforced (i.e. regulation, conditions on statutory authorizations, requirements to restore prior to issue of access to public land etc. are possible mechanisms but not clearly identified in subregional plans).

C. Monitoring Section

Describe the approach for monitoring habitat conditionsN 
Describe the approach for monitoring protection measuresN 

D. Timelines Section

Outline expected timelines for reporting on range plan implementation and monitoringYThe plans will be reviewed every 5 and 10 years.  There is no indication of how progress will be monitored. No indication interim reporting is planned.

The draft sub-regional plans fail as caribou range plans 

Ultimately, the caribou recovery goal is to achieve self-sustaining local populations in all boreal caribou ranges throughout their current distribution in Canada to stabilize and achieve self-sustaining status for the 37 not self-sustaining local populations.  This, in turn, requires a minimum 65% undisturbed habitat in a range in order to provide a 60% probability that a local population will become self-sustaining.   

The role of a range plan is to outline how range-specific land and/or resource activities will be managed over space and time to ensure that sufficient critical habitat for boreal caribou is protected from destruction. A range plan should therefore outline the measures and steps that will be taken to manage the interaction between human disturbance, natural disturbance, and the need to maintain or establish an ongoing, dynamic state of a minimum of 65% of the range as undisturbed habitat at any point in time to achieve or maintain a self-sustaining local population.  The draft plans for the Caribou Mountains, Red Earth and Berland sub-regions fail to do this.   

A mere assertion of a goal to achieve 65% undisturbed habitat at 100 years is not enough.  While limits on activities and restoration of caribou habitat are valid and necessary to achieve this goal, a range plan must do more than merely state that’s the plan.  There needs to be clearly identified and monitored baselines, thresholds and modelling to make achieving the goal a realistic possibility.  The limits on activities and requirements for restoration must be given the force of law to be enforceable and accountable.  Furthermore, those limits and requirements should be based upon the actual critical habitat needs of caribou not upon the most economically expedient place to conserve habitat.   

Furthermore, although the federal Range Plan Guideline is not binding, it does provide a logical and coherent path to range restoration and meeting scientific objectives.  By failing to meet the items outlined in the federal Range Plan Guideline, it is arguable that the province is failing to meet its obligations under the Canada-Alberta Conservation Agreement.  The federal government could, as a result, seek increased clarity and binding objectives to meet the intent of the conservation agreements. 

The Minister of ECCC may consider the range plans in assessing whether critical habitat protection is in place or being pursued within Alberta. If there is not sufficient provincial protection in place, then the Minister is required to recommend that a protection order under sections 34 and/or 61 of the Species of Risk Act be made in order to drop the federal safety net of caribou protection in the face of insufficient legislative and policy action by the province.   

Featured Photo by Barnabas Davoti from Pexels: https://www.pexels.com/photo/porcupine-caribou-standing-on-brown-grass-field-12977920/: A solitary caribou with impressive antlers stands on a rocky, grassy plain under bright daylight, showcasing nature’s beauty.


THANKS FOR YOUR SUPPORT

Your support is vital for stronger environmental legislation. As Alberta’s leading environmental charity, the Environmental Law Centre has served our community for over 40 years, providing objective guidance on crucial legislative changes. Your contribution helps protect our environment for future generations. 

Please support our work: Share, engage and donate to the ELC

Support Stronger Environmental Legislation

We provide objective information and respected advice on changing environmental legislation and regulations; we are one of the only charities in Alberta that provide this to Albertans.